MODEL OF FAITH AND RATIONALITY INTERACTION
MODEL OF FAITH AND RATIONALITY INTERACTION
The key philosophical issue regarding the problem of faith and reason is to work out how the authority of faith and the
authority of reason interrelate in the process by which a religious belief is
justified or established as true or justified. Rationalism holds
that truth should be determined by reason and factual analysis, rather
than faith, dogma, tradition or religious teaching. Fideism holds that faith is necessary,
and that beliefs may be held without any evidence or reason and even in
conflict with evidence and reason Four basic models of interaction are
possible. (a) The conflict model.
Here the aims, objects, or methods of reason and faith seem to be very much the
same. Thus when they seem to be saying different things, there is genuine
rivalry. This model is thus assumed both by religious fundamentalists, who
resolve the rivalry on the side of faith, and scientific naturalists, who resolve it on the side of reason. (b) The incompatibilist model. Here the aims, objects, and
methods of reason and faith are understood to be distinct. Compartmentalization
of each is possible. Reason aims at empirical truth; religion aims at divine
truths. Thus no rivalry exists between them. This model subdivides further into
three subdivisions. First, one can hold faith is transrational, inasmuch as it is higher than reason.
This latter strategy has been employed by some Christian existentialists.
Reason can only reconstruct what is already implicit in faith or religious
practice. Second, one can hold that religious belief is irrational, thus not subject to rational evaluation at
all. This is the position taken ordinarily by those who adopt negative
theology, the method that assumes that all speculation about God can only
arrive at what God is not. The latter subdivision also includes those theories
of belief that claim that religious language is only metaphorical in nature.
This and other forms of irrationalism result in what is ordinarily considered
fideism: the conviction that faith ought not to be subjected to any rational
elucidation or justification. (c) The weak compatibilist model.
Here it is understood that dialogue is possible between reason and faith,
though both maintain distinct realms of evaluation and cogency. For example,
the substance of faith can be seen to involve miracles;
that of reason to involve the scientific method of hypothesis testing. Much of
the Reformed model of Christianity adopts this basic model. (d) The strong compatibilist model. Here it is understood that
faith and reason have an organic connection, and perhaps even parity. A typical
form of strong compatibilism is termed natural theology. Articles of faith can be demonstrated by reason, either deductively
(from widely shared theological premises) or inductively (from common
experiences). It can take one of two forms: either it begins with justified
scientific claims and supplements them with valid theological claims
unavailable to science, or it starts with typical claims within a theological
tradition and refines them by using scientific thinking. An example of the
former would be the cosmological proof for God's existence; an example of the latter
would be the argument that science would not be possible unless God's goodness
ensured that the world is intelligible. Many, but certainly not all, Roman
Catholic philosophers and theologians hold to the possibility of natural
theology. Some natural theologians have attempted to unite faith and reason
into a comprehensive metaphysical system. The strong compatibilist model,
however, must explain why God chose to reveal Himself at all since we have such
access to him through reason alone. The interplay between reason and faith is
an important topic in the philosophy of religion. It is closely related to, but
distinct from, several other issues in the philosophy of religion: namely, the
existence of God, divine attributes, the problem of evil, divine action in the
world, religion and ethics, religious experience and religious language, and
the problem of religious pluralism. Moreover, an analysis of the interplay
between faith and reason also provides resources for philosophical arguments in
other areas such as metaphysics, ontology, and epistemology.

Comments
Post a Comment